STP vs ECN Forex Brokers: What’s The Difference?

In general, ECN firms have a distinct advantage over STP when it comes to providing ample liquidity sources. However, the liquidity capabilities of both broker types must be weighed against their respective values. For example, while STP brokers might offer lower costs, their lackluster liquidity pools might offset the negative impact of decreased trading commissions. Thus, the correct approach is to weigh the positives and negatives of each offering and consider if the corresponding liquidity pools are deep enough for specific trading needs.

  • On an ECN account, one can make trades on the currency markets directly in the electronic communication network (ECNs) without any intermediaries between the trader and other market participants.
  • Because an ECN instantly matches orders from traders with the best available buy and sell prices from all participants in the forex market, this typically results in tighter bid-ask spreads.
  • Market prices fluctuate reflecting the supply, demand, volatility and other market conditions.
  • ECNs, or electronic communication networks, are computerized networks in which traders can trade directly with one another.

ECN functions as an automated system that matches market participants’ orders directly. Because the broker only passes trades through, there is no dealing desk downside, such as price requotes that might delay the execution. Because an ECN instantly matches orders from traders with the best available buy and sell prices from all participants in the forex market, this typically results in tighter bid-ask spreads. Along with ECNs, matching systems and call markets are also considered forms of alternative trading systems.

ECN Brokers vs. Dealing Desk Brokers

The main downside to using an ECN broker is the commissions you may incur. These fees are calculated on a per-trade basis, so can be costly over the long-term. Investopedia does not provide tax, investment, or financial services and advice. The information is presented without consideration of the investment objectives, risk tolerance, or financial circumstances of any specific investor and might not be suitable for all investors.

what is ecn trading

It leveled the playing field, giving all market participants the same access and opportunities. A trader may enter an order to buy or sell at the current market price, but instead of having his or her order instantly filled, they are presented with a requote at a new market price. The only way to make sure that a forex broker is a true ECN broker is to make sure that you are trading with a regulated broker. Any regulated brokerage firm will provide information regarding its regulated status on its website. Another disadvantage of using ECNs is that the platform is less user-friendly than those provided by traditional brokers.

How ECNs Work

The minimum lot, as a rule, is strictly regulated, and most often, at least 0.1 lot is provided. ECNs are generally facilitated by electronic negotiation, a type of communication between agents that allows cooperative and competitive sharing of information to determine a proper price. Trading pairs consist of one currency priced against another currency.

what is ecn trading

Some of these unregulated brokers claim to be ECN brokers but are, in fact, dealing desk brokers. Also, if they are passing orders on to a market maker, that makes for slower order execution, which can result in clients’ orders being filled at less favorable prices. In summary, a forex ECN broker uses the MT4 or MT5 trading platforms, and manages ECN trading as a ‘hub’, where all the major market players act as a liquidity source. The broker uses this network to provide its clients with direct access to other participants in the market. Market markers set both the bid and the ask prices on their systems and display them publicly on their quote screens.

These squeezes offer opportunities for trading, but they often require different strategies and more caution than traditional breakouts. Have you ever seen a stock exhibiting normal trading behavior and then all of a sudden the stock price drastically drops out of nowhere? This type of price action could be related to the announcement of a shelf offering or the execution of an “at-the-market” sale from…

As of 2005, most e-business negotiation systems can only support price negotiations. Traditional negotiations typically include discussion of other attributes of a deal, such as delivery terms or payment conditions. This one-dimensional approach is one of the reasons why electronic markets struggle for acceptance. Multiattributive and combinatorial auction mechanisms are emerging to allow further types of negotiation. Successful trading relies on having good information about the market for a stock.

ECN brokers charge a volume-based commission rate while minimizing or, in some instances, eliminating the spread. This approach allows for better trade planning because total fees are just a simple calculation away. Support for complex multi-attribute negotiations is a critical success factor for the next generation of electronic markets and, more generally, for all types of electronic exchanges. This is what the second type of electronic negotiation, namely Negotiation Support, addresses.

Commission fees

An ECN broker is a financial intermediary that uses electronic communications networks (ECNs) to give clients direct access to other participants in equity and currency markets. Because an ECN broker consolidates price quotations from several market participants, it can generally offer its clients tighter bid/ask spreads than would be otherwise ecn trading available to them. An ECN account is a type of trading accounts provided by an ECN broker who usually has the role of the liquidity provider. On an ECN account, one can make trades on the currency markets directly in the electronic communication network (ECNs) without any intermediaries between the trader and other market participants.

ECN trading is an extremely efficient process using sophisticated technology. Linking all traders, large and small, directly with liquidity providers eliminates the need for a ‘middleman’ in your transactions. Electronic communication network (ECN) fees are applied on a per-trade basis, usually fractions of a cent. ECNs charge a service fee for matching buyers and sellers who trade on their exchange and networks. ECNs offer lower transaction costs since they eliminate these middlemen when trading securities. Online brokerages, institutional investors, and day traders alike prefer to use ECNs because of their speed and lower costs.

Trades are carried out immediately and at significantly thinner spreads. It motivates them to deliver the lowest possible rates in a bid to beat the competition and attract traders. The broker will charge a fixed commission every time you trade, as this is their profit. That said, it is certainly more transparent than the costs involved when using a market marker. One of the biggest drawbacks to using an ECN is the price to pay for using it. Typically, the fees and commissions for using an ECN are higher as compared to non-ECN systems.

A Caution for Traders

In addition, ECNs can make it easier for traders to execute international orders. Another way to ensure that you’re dealing with a genuine ECN broker is that ECN brokers do not present traders with the problem of requotes. Compared to standard brokers, your ECN brokerage can offer much tighter spreads as there is no ‘middleman’. Price quotations are gathered from numerous market participants, meaning ECN trading avoids wider spreads.

Matching systems receive orders and route the activity through a matching engine instance where the prices are checked against current resting limit orders. If no match is found, the order is placed in the book immediately as a quote. Call markets accept orders one at a time, with buying and selling prices determined based on the exchange activity after the order is placed. Classified by the SEC as an alternative trading system (ATS), an ECN makes money by charging a fee for each transaction to meet financial obligations. Orders placed through ECNs are usually limit orders, which is particularly useful for safely trading after hours, given the volatile effect that can have on a stock’s price.

what is ecn trading

The spread is typically kept lower than that investors can find in ECNs due to the fact that market makers generate their profit via the spread. Whereas ECN brokers mostly benefit from a commission on every trade, STP brokers also earn their income through spreads. Therefore, utilizing STP brokers might prove more expensive for traders with high transaction volumes. Thus, Forex brokers play a vital role both directly and indirectly in simplifying the Forex trading process for professional traders. Forex brokers come in various types and facilitate trader efforts in different ways. Therefore, it is crucial to understand which type of Forex broker is best for a specific trading practice.

ECNs are electronic communication networks that display the best bid and offer, efficiently matching orders across participants automatically. ECN brokers also offer abundant liquidity levels to their customers, having access to large liquidity provider institutions. On the contrary, STP brokers generally do not have access to ample liquidity pools, as they accommodate traders with smaller transactional needs. As a result, their processed transactions might be susceptible to slippage and fail to process orders swiftly.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *